Skip to main content

TIFU by instructing all of my company's upper management to look at a list of vibrators during a meeting.

I'm a biomedical engineer, I make cool medical devices. A really, really important part of developing medical devices is to understand the necessary regulations to ensure that the FDA doesn't drop the hammer on you.

Brief FDA background: I'm going to grossly oversimplify this for brevity's sake, but every medical device category has a 3 letter product code that determines how its reviewed and the controls that are put on it. If there isn't an existing code, then they'll make a new one for it. For some low-to-moderate risk devices, you can point to an existing device on the market and use it as a benchmark for safety. "This device is on the market and is safe. We have a bunch of data to show we're substantially equivalent. Please don't make us do years of human studies to demonstrate that our new tongue depressor design won't kill anyone." The FDA has a super handy database where you can type in the product code and it'll give you a list of all devices under that produce code that were cleared using this approach. It's here: https://www.accessdata.fda.gov/scripts/cdrh/cfdocs/cfPMN/pmn.cfm

Unfortunately, when you search a product code, it's done dynamically at the same URL. So if you want to share search results, you need to instruct others to repeat the search. I was presenting our regulatory strategy to all of upper management for a new medical device. I told them to bring up that site.

What I intended to say was this: "We plan to pursue regulatory clearance for our new system using one of the previously cleared devices under product code KQX as a predicate device. Go ahead and search it to see some examples."

That should have popped up devices under product KQX: "Goniometer, Ac-Powered"

Instead, what I actually said was this: "We plan to pursue regulatory clearance for our new system using one of the previously cleared devices under product code KXQ as a predicate device. Go ahead and search it to see some examples."

I waited about 15 seconds for anyone to say "yeah, I see what you mean," but it was dead silent. Everyone had very confused looks on their faces. For I had misspoke and unintentionally instructed them to look at all previously cleared devices under product code KXQ: "Vibrator For Therapeutic Use, Genital".

Because I'm far better versed in FDA regulations than upper management, when the first person broke the silence and asked "Uh, I don't think this will work," I doubled down and responded with "look, some of them may not seem like a perfect match, but the 510(k) definition of substantial equivalence is pretty wide. I've seen a tongue-controlled communication device (similar to the system a quadriplegic would use to control their wheelchair) get cleared using an ergonomic keyboard as a predicate device. I have little doubt."

There was a long silence before another person chimed in with "you feel that you can argue to the FDA that our [REDACTED PRODUCT NAME] is substantially equivalent to the 'Viberect Penile Vibratory Stimulation Device?'"

It was only then that I realized that I'd fucked up. After a quick clarification, I gave them the proper product code and we moved on.

TL;DR - Switching two letters in our in-development medical device's product code gives the product code for genital vibrators. Guess which one I told upper management to review.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

TIFU by forgetting my purse and attempting to get fuel

Not the craziest story but hey. I'm obligated to say this was a few months ago but I cringe every time I go past the petrol station . My petrol was getting low, not dangerously so but it said 27 miles left, (oftentimes it then suddenly drops to about 16 for example, and then 5 and then 0 very fast) I didnt have my purse on me as I just didn't need it... Picked my daughter up from school and then went on to collect my 2 stepdaughters from across town and then set off for home. En route the gauge went to 7 and then suddenly it was 1 so I stopped at the petrol station near our house. The petrol was on 0 as i pulled up to the pump and that's when I realised I had no money. I left the kids in the car at the pump and went in to talk to the cashier, it wasn't mega busy but there was a queue, I'd heard that they can help you if you can't pay for fuel. Like keeping something of yours as security. It was an elderly man and he basically refused to help. At this point i...

TIFU - Don’t do what I did

On Sunday morning Aug. 24th, I awoke to discover a large blind spot in my right eye, which turned out to be what is called wet age-related macular degeneration (AMD). It has resulted in a very significant, permanent loss of vision in that eye. Although I maintain good peripheral vision, whatever I focus on at best is very blurry, and mostly disappears. I can barely make out the large E at the top of the eye chart. If this happens to my left eye I’ll be unable to read or drive. It turns out that I missed the opportunity that I had to prevent this from becoming a serious problem because I failed to report what appeared to be minor changes in my vision. In the weeks prior to August I had noticed that what I knew to be straight lines appeared to my right eye to have a little waviness. I also noticed that the color of my front lawn, which I could see through the window from my recliner,  was subdued, looked almost gray, in my right eye. So I scheduled an eye exam, which revealed the p...

TIFU by getting suspended for 2 days by my front office in school.

I (13M) am an African American student at Jeannette junior high who had got suspended for 2 days here. I was in math class minding my business until my teacher had told me to go to the main office, which posed no problem to me. As i went down there, the people of the front office had stopped me and made me get a new ID (yes, we have id's.) so i had asked them if i could maybe do a different alternative and call my mother to let her bring the Id here, even then, the Id isn't that important. So, although i was talking to them in a calm manner and not showing any signs of rebellion, they had threatened to call the police on me without thinking twice before calling my parents. This is where i started getting angry, and even then now the black peers agree that could have been a racially motivated action. They then told me to sit in the office conference room because of that, leading into more anger. They had then called my mother who had came over to the school didn't even let ...